FR. MORTON A. HILL, S.J.
Defender of the Public Decencies
Introduction by Rev. Paul Murphy, S.J.
Morality is unfortunately not a welcome or frequent word in the public
discourse of our time. Morality speaks of basic standards of right conduct,
with special reference to virtue in sexual conduct. But morality is the
word deliberately chosen by Father Hill to give title and focus to the organization
he founded and directed for twenty-three years. The title and focus remain
in an organization grown to national stature. Morality in Media, Inc. has
developed a central office in New York with a permanent staff. It hosts
and sustains the National Obscenity Law Center as a full resource of expert
reference in the critical area of legal controls of public obscenity.
There are those who scoff at morality as alien to the liberties of
a free people. Fr. Hill saw it otherwise and his vision carried the wisdom
of that irreplaceable human dignity nourished in the integrity of family
life, where the human life power is honored and served in an ambience
of disciplined and generous love. Uncompromising conviction led him to
confront promiscuity and perversion as the corruption of human dignity
and the corrosion of family life. He saw clearly that morality was not
merely private but also public a matter of community standards and controls
over the marketplace, the promotion of a social environment conducive
to decency in personal and family life.
He started as one small voice in an urban setting. With unswerving
determination and by ceaseless labor, his voice grew to national resonance.
He never sought nor did he get easy success in his unselfish campaign.
Yet he gradually won the respect and support of thousands.
Worried mothers and fathers contributed from their small resources;
leaders in business and finance responded to his constant appeals and
gave from their abundance. Religious leaders across the spectrum of American
life joined him in a campaign whose validity they could not deny, pushed
by the alarming growth of moral septicemia in the national bloodstream.
Through it all he was primarily a man of God, serving a loved nation
in its original character as a God-loving people, whose inalienable rights
and dignity were solemnly recognized as God's gifts. For him and for the
unnumbered many who joined him, God's moral law was not only an invitation
to human dignity but the imperative of a civil society serving its citizens
in the pursuit of the true measure of human happiness possible on earth.
FATHER MORTON HILL and MORALITY IN MEDIA
THE ODYSSEY OF A CONCERNED AND DETERMINED LEADER
"Better look into this," the Jesuit pastor suggested to the parish priest
late in 1962. "This" was a situation that had arisen in the parish elementary
school, where a mother had discovered that sadomasochistic magazines were
circulating among sixth grade boys.
"Looking into" the pornography traffic brought Fr. Morton A. Hill,
S.J. to the White House in March of 1983, where, with a group of other
concerned clergy and lay persons, he asked the President of the United
States to look into it and direct the Department of Justice to enforce
the federal obscenity laws which had been sitting on the books almost
unused for seven years.
The original suggestion of the superior twenty three years ago eventuated
in the mounting of a community campaign on the upper East Side of Manhattan
in New York City, for which Fr. Hill recruited a Lutheran minister, Rev.
Robert E. Wiltenburg, and Rabbi Julius G. Neumann.
A YORKVILLE RECTORY OFFICE
Working out of a small office in St. Ignatius Loyola parish rectory on Park
Avenue in Manhattan, and holding planning meetings in an East Side synagogue,
the group called "Operation Yorkville" set about raising public consciousness
about the type of pornographic material that was reaching children. They
began to research the problem and the law. They shared what they learned
with area church groups and organizations. They addressed meetings of those
groups. They took to radio and television whenever possible, and they disseminated
a mimeographed newsletter.
It soon became obvious they were filling a need, as requests for
information and speakers came to them from every corner of New York City,
then from New Jersey and Connecticut and beyond.
In 1966, with the small rectory office bulging with research and
hardly able to accommodate the part-time typist for whom Fr. Hill scraped
up $10 each day, the priest moved the office to commercial quarters on
Lexington Avenue where he took on another part-time typist. At the same
time, the United States Supreme Court handed down its Fanny Hill decision
which was to give the pornographers an almost unqualified green light
to move their wares. Three justices held that a work must be "utterly
without redeeming social value" to be declared obscene. Under such a test,
nothing would be obscene. But, even though the specious test was not a
decision of the Court majority, but only of three justices, the pornographers'
defenders took it, ran with it, and convinced lower courts time after
time to declare not obscene material that was becoming increasingly depraved.
Fr. Hill enlisted the assistance of three volunteer lawyers who studied
the decision and maintained that "utterly" was not the law of the land.
Early in 1967, having built a board of directors to guide the three clergymen,
he retained a professional writer to help spread that legal word; and
late that year he had the fledgling group, now called Morality in Media,
incorporated as a not-for-profit corporation in the State of New York.
APPOINTED TO COMMISSION
Also late that year, word of Morality in Media and its work having spread
through the country, Fr. Hill was appointed by President Lyndon B. Johnson
to a Commission on Obscenity and Pornography. The Commission had been created
by Congress because the traffic in pornography had become "a matter of national
concern."
However, any hope that the Commission's work would bring a slow-down
to the accelerating pornography traffic was quickly dashed when news of
its makeup emanated from the White House. Of the 18 appointed members,
two-thirds were ideologues who held absolutist positions on the First
Amendment, or represented vested interests. It was a sure bet the majority,
operating from pre-conceived notions, would recommend repeal of obscenity
laws. Even more certain was the fact that Morality in Media, Inc., which
Fr. Hill had said from the beginning was "in business to go out of business,"
would not soon be going out of business.
He quickly enlisted the services of Paul J. McGeady, an astute lawyer
who had served on a New York City pornography commission, and Victor B.
Cline, a noted behavioral scientist from the University of Utah. At the
end of the Commission's life in 1970, with the help of the two experts,
Fr. Hill and a fellow clergyman on the Commission, Dr. Winfrey C. Link,
issued the Hill-Link Minority Report. The Congress rejected the majority
report which, as predicted, recommended repeal of the obscenity laws,
and the Hill-Link Report was read into the record in both Houses.
Three years later in its landmark obscenity decisions, the United
States Supreme Court was to cite the Hill-Link Report several times and
completely ignore the majority report.
HILL-LINK RECOMMENDATION
Shortly after the issuance of the report, Fr. Hill became an almost weekly
commuter on the New York-Washington shuttle, working to obtain federal funding
to activate one of the recommendations of his report that a clearinghouse
of legal information on the law of obscenity be established to service overburdened,
underpaid prosecutors so that they could become the equals of the highly
paid, highly skilled defense attorneys in the courtroom.
While testifying as an expert witness for the government in a New
Orleans trial, he met Homer Young, a retired FBI agent who was also testifying,
and who was teaching courses in criminal justice at California Lutheran
College. With the grant finally obtained after numerous meetings with
Department of Justice officials, the recommended clearinghouse or center
opened early in 1972 on the campus of Cal Lutheran, staffed by Homer Young
and three former prosecutors.
Meanwhile, having observed that the work and propaganda of the American
Civil Liberties Union, with its network of local organizations and cooperating
attorneys, had had much to do with creating the tangled legal morass into
which obscenity law had descended, Fr. Hill determined to organize a similar
network to untangle the mess.
BEGINS ORGANIZING
Early in 1970 Morality in Media conducted its first organizational meeting
in Chicago, training attendees to structure state affiliates of the now-national
organization. The first affiliate, Morality in Media of Massachusetts, was
established by Fr. Paul J. Murphy, S.J., then teaching at Boston College.
In 1973, in Miller v. California, the nation's highest Court
laid to rest once and for all the "utterly without redeeming social value"
idea:
"We do not adopt as a constitutional standard the (utterly)
test; that concept has never commanded the adherence of more than three
justices at one time"
In a decision handed down the same day, the Court "categorically" disapproved
the "consenting adults" concept, created in the late '60's by libertarian
elements and defense attorneys. Citing the Hill-Link Report as indicating
that there is at least an "arguable correlation between obscene material
and crime:" the Court said,
"Rights and interests other than those of the advocates
are involved...these include the interest of the public in the quality
of life...the total community environment, the tone of commerce in the
great city centers, and possibly the public safety itself"
The Court set up a new, workable test for obscenity (works which taken
as a whole appeal to the prurient interest, are patently offensive, and
which taken as a whole do not have serious value).
It appeared now that all that Fr. Hill and Morality in Media needed
to do was see that all the states adopted the Court's test (which the
Court construed into existing federal laws). New York was the first and
was based on language Paul McGeady provided. But, the ACLU was omnipresent
in state legislatures, and to this day there are still seven states with
ineffective obscenity laws, and three states with no obscenity laws at
all.
Meanwhile, a West Coast defense attorney, backed by a libertarian
organization, began an attack, shortly after the landmark decisions, against
the California clearinghouse which was thriving and had become an invaluable
tool for prosecutors. They took the attack all the way into the office
of Attorney General Edward Levi in 1975, maintaining that its presence
on the campus of California Lutheran College violated separation of church
and state. They succeeded in having federal funding cut off.
FR. HILL ESTABLISHES NATIONAL OBSCENITY LAW CENTER
Fr. Hill took to the road again, and in 1976 re-opened the National Obscenity
Law Center in New York with funding from the private sector. It now has
Paul McGeady at the helm as Director, and is located in the Morality in
Media's offices on Manhattan's Riverside Drive, near Columbia University.
The Center is now considered the most authoritative source on obscenity
law in the country.
It was also in the era of Edward Levi that federal obscenity prosecutions
began to decline until they were at a mere trickle. Obscenity investigator
Homer Young, an expert on the organized crime scene, (the mob controls
90 percent of the hardcore pornography traffic in the country) maintains
that the back of the entire industry could be broken in 18 months with
vigorous enforcement of existing laws.
43-CITY ALERT TOUR
With pornography spreading, Fr. Hill set off on a seven-month national Town
Meeting Tour in October 1981 to alert the country to the illegal traffic
in pornography and the emergence of cableporn. He was the first to warn,
"Pornography is no longer just downtown, it's now downstairs" via cable
television. Visiting 43 towns and cities from Wahoo, Nebraska to St. Paul,
Minnesota, from Ft. Dodge, Iowa to St. Petersburg, Florida, Father Hill
listened to the voice of the people and urged everyone to write to the U.S.
Attorney General (at that point, William French Smith), urging vigorous
enforcement of the federal obscenity laws.
Nonetheless, only token enforcement of the obscenity laws persisted
while the pornography traffic burgeoned, and it was this deteriorating
situation that brought Fr. Hill to the White House. "The token enforcement
mentality of the U.S. Department of Justice has become so entrenched that
only intervention by the President himself can change it." he asserted.

Fr. Hill meets President Reagan,
March 1983 |
Fr. Hill brought together a coalition
of concerned national leaders who met with White House staff and enforcement
agency officials, and in March 1983, they met with the President himself
and the heads of the agencies, and recommended a coordinator to pull
the agencies together for aggressive enforcement. As a result of this
meeting, a White House Working Group on Pornography was formed in
June of 1983, and in December, President Reagan addressed the nation's
U.S. Attorneys and called for tighter enforcement of the laws.
|
Fr. Hill also had long advocated that obscenity be included in the crimes
covered by the Federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Law
(RICO). In January of 1984, he and Morality in Media suggested to Congress
that such an amendment be added to the Crime Control bill then under consideration.
In October of 1984, President Reagan signed into law the 635-page
Comprehensive Crime Control Act, which contains the amendment adding obscenity
to the list of enumerated crimes covered by the Federal RICO Law. The
inclusion of obscenity in RICO gives power to the Justice Department to
confiscate the pornographer's business and assets related to the criminal
enterprise.
In June 1984, under Fr. Hill's guidance, Morality in Media sponsored
the National Catholic Conference on the Illegal Sex Industry in New York
City, as step one in a five-year plan to increase denominational involvement
in the pornography issue.
In the spring of 1985, Morality in Media sponsored the non-denominational
Denver National Conference on Pornography which launched a year-long "People
vs. Pornography" campaign. Features of that campaign are regional "People
vs. Pornography" workshops throughout the country and the initiation of
Fr. Hill's idea to blanket the United States with public information leaflets
designed to inform the public and create a climate in which law enforcement
may flourish.
WORK WILL CONTINUE
His People vs. Pornography campaign is ongoing, as is the single minded
goal of Father Morton A. Hill, S.J. to knock out the illegal porn industry
to protect our children and society from the ravages of pornography. Morality
in Media,, inspired by the example set by the beloved priest, will not "go
out of business" until that goal is accomplished.
FULL STEAM AHEAD UNTIL THE END
The national distribution of public information leaflets was a priority
with him getting out to the public the straight facts on the pornography
industry and obscenity law, to create a climate in which law enforcement
will flourish. Each day he asked for a report, and exclaimed with delight
when he would hear that another 20,000 had been ordered in one, not atypical,
day. Father Hill was also feeding the staff new ideas for a second set of
leaflets with which to blanket the grass roots of America.
| "In the next 12 months, all will
pull together... when this happens, know it happened because of you:'
wrote Father Hill to his staff on October 1st. "Your efforts will
pay off rich dividends, perhaps not material, but spiritual." The
letter ended, "With God, all things are possible. I love you all"
The uneven handwriting indicated that Father's physical strength
was waning. The message, however, indicated that his determination
to defeat the porn industry was stronger than ever. It proved to
be Father Hill's last letter to Morality in Media.
|

The genial face of Father Morton A. Hill, porn fighter |
On the day that Father Hill passed away, the MIM staff sat, stunned, long
after "closing time:' There was a need to be together for solace and to
exchange fond memories. "What was it about Father Hill that you loved?"
became the question of the day The answers came spontaneously: "his gentleness:'"his
holiness and piety '"the warm twinkle in his eyes," "his thoughtfulness
and complete honesty in dealing with others ' "his perseverance." One MlM'er
loved the way he bicycled enthusiastically to work in his clerical suit
and a big, white helmet."
One staff member mentioned Father Hill's "thirst for knowledge,"
recalling how MlM's president earned a law degree by studying on airplanes,
took courses in conservation and accounting and then became a licensed
locksmith after deciding that he wanted to do something with his hands.
Another member of the staff, recalling how she met Father Hill, said that
while doing free lance work in the building, she was approached by the
white-haired priest in the cafeteria one day. "You look like someone I
ought to know," he said. "What do you do?" Vintage Morton A. Hill: An
unflagging interest in people.
There could be no doubt, however, that what inspired everyone most
of all about Father Hill was his unconquerable and indefatigable spirit
in battling the illegal sex industry. His vision was pure and his commitment
to decency contagious. The younger members of MlM's staff, in particular,
spoke of how rare it is to find someone "with the courage to stand up
for what's right."
During the eulogy at Father Hill's Mass of Christian Burial, the
homilist noted that Father Hill had three families: his natural family,
his Jesuit family and his Morality in Media family. That MIM family includes
not just his staff, but also the thousands upon thousands of Americans
from coast to coast who have supported him throughout the years. And when
Father Hill ended his last letter with "l love you all," he meant all.
Father Hill's plans will be carried forward by his determined MIM
staff and his extended family across the nation.